
Return to Amish Star Sabrina Burkholder Shares Racy Naked Photo After Giving Birth to Baby No 6
Return to Amish alum Sabrina Burkholder shared a racy nude photo of herself on Instagram just over two years after she gave birth to baby No. 6.
The reality star, 38, took to her Instagram Stories on Sunday, March 16, to share a selfie in which she wore nothing from the waist up and covered her chest with one hand. Sabrina also added text over her chest that read, “New content is up,” promoting her OnlyFans account.
Sabrina’s scantily clad post came just over two years after she surprised fans with the news that she had welcomed her sixth child, her first with now-ex-boyfriend Scottie Harville, after keeping her pregnancy a secret.
“Baby boy Aro Reno, born 2/23/23,” she wrote on Instagram in February 2023. “In Hebrew, Aro (pronounced like Arrow) means ‘bearer of martyrs, exalted, enlightened, mountain of strength.’”
Meanwhile, she exclusively told In Touch at the time, “My boyfriend Scottie and I welcomed Aro with open arms, and we are very, very happy!”
The mom of six also shares son Zekiah and daughters Skylar and Kalani with ex-boyfriend Jethro Nolt, as well as daughters Oakley and Arianna with ex-boyfriend Harry Kreiser III.
Four months before Sabrina announced the news of Aro’s birth, In Touch exclusively confirmed that the TLC personality had split from Jethro in August 2022 after more than five years of dating and that the two were focused on coparenting.

Sabrina, who appeared on all seven seasons of Return to Amish from 2014 to 2023, introduced viewers to Jethro during season 6 in March 2021. However, the two had been dating since 2017, when the former Mennonite was pregnant and expecting her first child with her now-ex.
Sabrina previously explained to In Touch that she and Jethro knew “each other for a long time” before they started seeing each other romantically.
“Jethro’s father is a preacher in the conservative Mennonite church,” she said in a January 2019 interview. “I’m excited to have a boy! God has redeemed me and I am so grateful.”
Sabrina moved on with Scottie, 30, after her split from Jethro. While it’s unclear exactly when the Breaking Amish alum and Scottie ended their relationship, Sabrina confirmed that it was over in a rare life update in February detailing her ex’s arrest on domestic battery charges.
“In September 2024, my ex was charged with strangulation, kidnapping, and tampering with a witness. I found out last week that I’ve been walking around with a sprained neck for the past five months. Today I was referred to a neurosurgeon,” she wrote alongside a selfie on Instagram. “Posting this to remind y’all that you’re not alone. I go through s–t too. Here’s to all abuse survivors — I see you and I’m proud of you.”
Three days before her update, Sabrina took to Facebook to share Sarasota County, Florida, court paperwork revealing that Scottie was behind bars.
“He picked up a metal table and was holding it over my head ready to bash my skull in. Thank God I was able to call the cops, and he dropped the table and grabbed my phone. I will never forget running as fast as I could out the lane,” Sabrina claimed in her post. “If the cops hadn’t showed up immediately, while I was running for my life, I’d probably be dead. Thank God I managed to escape in the nick of time.”
Scottie was charged with kidnapping, false imprisonment, domestic battery by strangulation and tampering with a witness on September 13, 2024, according to Sarasota County, Florida, court docs obtained by In Touch. Sabrina filed a petition for injunction on October 15, 2024. A final judgment of the injunction for protection was served on October 30, 2024.
Scottie was found guilty and ordered to spend two years in jail, as well as serve two years of probation.
Scottie’s legal troubles didn’t end there, as he was charged with violating Sabrina’s protective order on February 4 after he repeatedly sent her letters from jail. He pleaded not guilty. His latest court appearance was on March 10, where prosecutors dropped the case.