See What the ‘Are You the One?’ Season 2 Alums Are Up to Now

A simple equation? Not in the least. After the highly successful debut season of Are You the One?, 20 new single contestants flew to San Juan, Puerto Rico, to identify their perfect matches for a shot at love and a cash prize. Of course, it’s much harder than it looks with feelings involved and a dating algorithm in play.

The group had the challenge of identifying 10 Perfect Matches while living together so they could all walk away with a portion of the $1 million award. As if that’s not enough pressure, they had an 11th girl thrown into the mix. 

Christina LeBlanc had no choice but to bring her A-game because she and another girl were destined to face-off as a mystery man’s Perfect Match before heading to the Truth Booth to find out which lady was better suited for him in the long run. 

After correctly guessing eight out of 10 Perfect Matches in episode 9, the squad was very strategic with their votes in hopes of reigning triumphant in the final choosing ceremony — and it worked out. The cast not only secured the money, but also walked away with some new fans.

Meanwhile, Jenni Knapmiller and Curtis Hadzicki, who was previously involved with Shelby Yardley from the show, have since gotten engaged. Curtis proposed in October 2020, writing in an Instagram caption of their engagement photo, “I’ll spend the rest of my life trying to properly thank you for all that you do. I love you forever.”

However, Shelby has also moved on as well and is now married to husband Brennan, having tied the knot in 2021. She’s also a mom to their adorable son, Sleven.

Many of the season 2 contestants have embarked on new journeys, relationships and career paths following their reality TV appearances. While some have stayed together, many have found new love elsewhere. Scroll through the gallery below to see what the AYTO? season 2 cast has been up to in the past few years.