Behind the Scenes of the ‘Bachelor: Women Tell All’ — Chris Flipped a Coin to Choose His Finalists!

The Bachelor’s Kaitlyn Bristowe was shocked to be sent home after a steamy overnight date in the Fantasy Suite with Chris Soules — and now, a source who was at the Feb. 21 taping of the Women Tell All special exclusively reveals to ‘In Touch’ why he sent her packing!

“Chris seemed really into her the whole time. So when she went home, it was a shock to everyone, especially Kaitlyn,” says a source who was at the Feb. 21 taping. “She asked Chris how he could blindside her like that.”

Chris and Kaitlyn on her hometown date.

Chris’ response made the audience gasp. “Chris said, ‘I flipped a coin!’ He had no other explanation,” the source reveals to ‘In Touch.’ “Kaitlyn wasn’t comforted by the fact that her fate was left to a 50-50 coin toss.”

And finalists Whitney Bischoff and Becca Tilley will likely be even more shocked when they find out. “I can only imagine what the winner is going to think,” adds the source, “when she learns that he’s marrying her because a coin landed on tails!”

For all of the insider details from ‘Women Tell All,’ pick up this week’s issue of ‘In Touch Weekly,’ on newsstands now!