90 Day Fiancé star Tim Malcolm couldn’t believe his eyes when he saw ex-girlfriend Jeniffer Tarazona on 90 Day: Hunt for Love.

The reality star, 44, appeared confused and shocked when his ex, 30, took off her mask and revealed her identity in the new spinoff’s trailer, which Tim shared on his Instagram on Friday, May 2.

“Who is this girl?” he said as he squinted his eyes and leaned in closer, seemingly recognizing Jeniffer. After she took off her mask, Tim said in a confessional, “You’ve gotta be f–king kidding me, man.”

In the caption, Tim wrote, “New trailer for the biggest and baddest #90dayfiance show in history. #90dayfiancehuntforlove premieres May 26th. Don’t miss it!”

Tim and Jeniffer met online in 2019 via a website designed for meeting Colombian women, as seen on 90 Day Fiancé: Before the 90 Days season 3. He traveled from Charlotte, North Carolina, to Jeniffer’s native country to meet her in person, and though the trip didn’t end in an engagement, they continued to date until their split was confirmed later that year.

“I haven’t actually talked to Jeniffer in a couple months,” Tim shared in an update during a June 2020 episode of 90 Day Fiancé: Self-Quarantined. “After the tell-all, Jeniffer and I were planning to get her a visa, but it was very expensive. So I told her, ‘Jeniffer, give me some time.’”

The North Carolina native also revealed that they had been arguing over his custom-made gun business prior to their breakup.

“And then of course, to her, that was like ‘Oh, you care more about your business.’ That started a series of arguments,” he continued. “She didn’t want to come anymore and we stopped talking. We were done.”

Following his split from Jeniffer, Tim — whose past relationship and close friendship with ex Veronica Rodriguez has also been frequently highlighted in the 90 Day franchise — moved on with exes Linda Ramirez and Luisa Beltran.

Meanwhile, Jeniffer dated franchise costar Darcey Silva’s former boyfriend Jesse Meester. Her rep confirmed to In Touch in September 2022 that they had separated.

Now, both Tim and Jeniffer are slated to appear on 90 Day: Hunt for Love, which was announced on April 24.

“90 DAY: HUNT FOR LOVE, an exhilarating rollercoaster ride featuring eight singles from the 90 Day universe who are ready to embark on a quest for love once again, joined by fresh, new faces and romantic hopefuls,” a press release teased. “Set in Tulum, Mexico, these love-hungry alums have loved, lost and learned a few lessons along the way. Whether they’re healing old wounds, chasing new sparks, or unknowingly walking straight into a love triangle, each of them throws caution to the wind as they jump back into the dating game.”

Joining the exes in Mexico are Tiffany Franco, Chantel Everett, Colt Johnson, Cortney Reardanz, Usman “Sojaboy” Umar and Rob Warne, who just completed his appearance with ex Sophie Sierra on 90 Day: The Last Resort season 2.

A teaser trailer teased Jeniffer landing in a love triangle with Rob, 33, and a new cast member named Cole.

“I really like him. Like, I wanna marry Cole. But I wanna f–k Rob,” she said as the camera cut to Rob and Cole getting into a heated argument.

“All’s fair in love and war … sometimes people get hurt,” Rob teased.