
Stars React to Michelle Trachtenberg's Death: Celebrity Tributes
Michelle Trachtenberg’s sudden death left an empty hole in the hearts of fans and former costars whom she worked with throughout her acting career. The Ice Princess actress died at age 39 inside her midtown Manhattan apartment on February 26, 2025, and was found “unconscious and unresponsive” when police arrived on the scene, the New York Police Department told In Touch.
Celebrities, including Michelle’s former costars Sarah Michelle Gellar and Blake Lively, publicly reacted to the 17 Again star’s death on social media and shared their fondest memories of her in heartfelt tributes.
Penn Badgley said in April 2025 that Michelle’s death was “really saddening,” while Leighton Meester called it “devastating.”
Between all the condolences, one message remained the same: Michelle was a force to be reckoned with and a bright light in a demanding business.